Sign-In

STORY

Share

Time to face the energy reality

Opinion

[8 Comment(s)]

By Jonathan Specht

Imagine a world in which oil production is declining, and prices are rising with no end in sight. Sooner or later, that world will be a reality. Peak oil is the point at which 50 percent of the world's oil - the easiest 50 percent to get to - has been extracted. From that point onward, production will decline while prices rise. Almost no one disputes that peak oil is coming (if we haven't reached it yet). The only questions are how soon it will hit, and how painful it will be for society.

President Obama has made it clear that America's rate of oil usage (25 percent of the world's usage for having 3 percent of the world's population) has to come down. In doing so, Obama has become the first president to take energy seriously in 30 years. Whatever his other problems, Jimmy Carter at least understood the importance of the issue more than his successors. This isn't a partisan critique: Bill Clinton was just as guilty of doing nothing about our looming energy crisis as Ronald Reagan or the two Bushes.

Conservatives need to face the reality that "drill, baby, drill" is a sexual innuendo, not a serious energy policy. Drilling off the coast of the U.S. won't prolong our current way of life for more than a year or two. The fact is that the United States hit its peak of oil production back in the early 1970s, and every corner of the country has been explored. There will be no new major American oil discoveries.

Liberals need to face the reality that wind, solar and hydroelectric power alone won't be enough to meet our energy demands, at least without a significant reduction in our standard of living. America needs to start building new nuclear power plants, and soon. Nuclear energy emits no greenhouse gases, and comes from a power source that will be around much longer than fossil fuels. Fortunately, President Obama was the only Democratic candidate in the 2008 primary to say he supported building new nuclear plants. Let's hope he keeps his word.

Americans of all persuasions need to acknowledge that a major energy problem is in demand, not just supply. On the rare occasions when our politicians address energy demand, it's usually in "demanding" that car companies increase the gas mileages of their vehicles. What few American politicians are willing to say is that we, the American people, need to step up to the plate and reduce our energy usage. We need to drive less, and carpool more.

We also need to demand more and better public transportation, and passenger rail service between cities. And we need to make our neighborhoods more walkable, so that it's possible to buy our morning coffee without going through five miles of traffic. Above all, we need to disabuse ourselves of the notion that it makes any kind of sense to live in suburbs 30 or 40 miles from our workplaces. 

The International Energy Agency predicts that we won't hit peak oil until 2030. On the other hand, Matthew Simmons, a former energy adviser to President George W. Bush, says we reached peak oil back in 2005. Whether we hit peak oil four years ago or will in 21 years, we need to start preparing for its potentially cataclysmic results. The only reason oil prices are low now is that the recession has reduced demand. When the economy recovers, gas prices of $4 or more per gallon are sure to return. Now is the time for all of us to get serious about energy, while we still can.

Originally Published: Issue 763 - April 29, 2009

Share on Facebook
Back to the top

Comments

  1. Oil prices will rise. However, there is no need to panic. Higher prices will encourage people to conserve and find alternatives.

    I car pool and it is a bit of a hassle but it saves me 75% of my commuting cost as I only drive my car 1/4 of the time to work. That means gas prices would have to rise 4X before I would spend as much as someone who does not carpool.

    You can’t control the big picture but you do have a lot of power to conserve the energy you use.

    Peter B | 2009-04-29 - 04:53:01 PM (CDT)
  2. "Nuclear energy emits no greenhouse gases"

    This is far from the truth, it emits a similar amount to gas fired power stations:
    http://www.acfonline.org.au/articles/news.asp?news_id=435
    And what about waste security in the future? can you guarantee we will still have the resources to keep waste secure for 1000’s years?

    Andy B | 2009-04-29 - 01:50:37 AM (CDT)
  3. Steve - This is a great article but your definition of "peak oil" is wrong. Peak oil has nothing to do with the amount of oil in the earth. Its all about production rate. Once production falls below demand (currently 85 million barrels/day) the world will experience shortages which will cause world wide depression, chaos, death and destruction.

    Gale Whitaker | 2009-04-30 - 02:59:14 AM (CDT)
  4. I think that this is a nice fluff piece that has very little to do with reality.

    1) Nuclear energy does emit greenhouse gases. Uranium must be mined and transported, and both require fossil fuels. Also, there’s not all that much uranium left.

    2) The information distributed by the IEA is overly optimistic and they admit as much. The Chief Economist of the IEA, Faith Birol, in in a YouTube video stating that 2020 is more like the peak, for all liquids, oil, tar sands oil, ethanol, LNG, etc.

    Don’t underestimate the severity of hitting peak oil. Economic growth will stop. Once the true reason is admitted by the media and politicians (maybe never), societal collapse is a real possibility.

    Andy P. | 2009-04-30 - 03:48:31 AM (CDT)
  5. "societal collapse is a real possibility. "
    The current paradigm will certainly have to change as it is patently unsustainable in its current form. The question is what kind of Phoenix, will rise from its ashes?

    Fred Magyar | 2009-04-30 - 11:02:12 AM (CDT)
  6. Not to worry, the problem will take care of itself... just not in a nice way.

    Earthbound Misfit | 2009-04-30 - 06:11:18 PM (CDT)
  7. Peak Oil mean that oil PRODUCTION will decrease. It does not necessarily mean that oil prices will always rise. Oil prices will rise enough to put the economy back into decline, so that oil consumption is reduced. Each economic cycle will increasingly favor decline. Continuously increasing prices would be the most optimistic scenario but this is not playing out due to extreme "stimulus" of the economy. At this point it looks like we are past peak. Even if not we are certainly past peak conventional, max EROEI, and max net BTU.
    Read more at: http://www.energystrain.com

    Dan Swanson | 2009-05-01 - 01:41:55 AM (CDT)
  8. Jonathan the author says: "...the American people, need to step up to the plate and reduce our energy usage. We need to drive less, and carpool more".
    Hey, the EU uses what, 10bbl oil per person per year, while we use what, 40bbl per year per person. People will not "step up to the plate" and economize on petroleum. The Europeans knew this and got consumption down by hugely taxing gasoline and diesel and heating oil and natural gas. They forced the sealing of homes and offices through law and more taxation. The European people have a much more representitive form of voting, citizens vote for people that win, and their views make the laws, not lobbyists. Their legislators can take no special interest monies.

    I digress, the populace discussed alternatives through their parties, and settled on limiting laws and taxes, which have worked. When their Christian Democrats (our Republicans) are in, they make no efforts to end the taxes and laws. Everybody is on board. Is the EU always hand wringing about dependence on foreign energy? Naaah. And they are dependent, much more than we are. The US still produces about 32% of its own oil. Why are we whining? Our special interests won’t let the US do what has to be done, and our legislators cover themselves by whining about energy independence.

    Pete M | 2009-05-04 - 01:51:34 AM (CDT)
Your Thoughts,
Name: (required)
To protect everyone from terrible spam, please enter the following code: (required)
captcha
* Offensive comments will be deleted!

ADVERTISEMENTS