Sign-In

STORY

Share

'New Moon' Improves on 'Twilight'

Movie Review

[16 Comment(s)]

By Jonathan Specht

Rating: B

This column is probably useless, since you've probably already made up your mind about The Twilight Saga: New Moon. Either you're hopelessly devoted to the Twilight franchise, or you're completely dismissive of the phenomenon and mystified by its popularity.

As everyone knows, the Twilight Saga is a set of four wildly popular books about a moody girl in Washington State (Bella) who falls in love with a sparkly vampire who refuses to suck human blood (Edward). Criticisms of the books range from the legitimate (the writing is pretty awful) to the ridiculous (they promote premarital abstinence).

The second film picks up where the first one left off, with Bella (Kristen Stewart) madly in love with Edward (Robert Pattinson). Things fall apart quickly, when Edward decides to break up with Bella for her own good and she falls into a multi-month depression. Eventually, Bella starts to get over Edward, thanks to a new man in her life: Jacob (Taylor Lautner), a Native American hunk who also happens to be a werewolf. Edward, however, refuses to let her be snatched away by another man (or rather, another supernatural being), and the last portion of the film concerns his efforts to get back into her life.

While the first movie had a few strong points, it was hobbled by its bad acting and even worse cinematography. Fortunately, New Moon doesn't share the flaws of its predecessor. The acting is much better overall, although neither Kristen Stewart (Bella) nor Robert Pattinson (Edward), deliver top-notch performances. New Moon is also much better directed than Twilight. Unlike in the previous film, there were no moments when I laughed out loud at terrible cinematography. The film also includes a number of good action scenes.

The film's real standout star is Taylor Lautner, who plays a frustratingly patient piece of man candy for the gloomy and obsessive Bella. Dakota Fanning, who somehow grew up, also plays an interesting role as an associate member of the inner circle of Vampire leadership.

New Moon is neither great nor terrible. It probably won't win any Oscars, but it will bring its producers hundreds of millions of dollars in ticket and DVD sales. I would offer one warning to anyone considering seeing it: be prepared to have your film experience interrupted by frequent shrieks from young teenage girls.

Originally Published: Issue 825 - December 2, 2009

Share on Facebook
Back to the top

Comments

  1. i luv new moon

    frANK | 2009-12-02 - 06:31:51 PM (CDT)
  2. the same as comment#1 said

    melissa | 2009-12-02 - 06:49:44 PM (CDT)
  3. edwrad is so hot when he walks out of the car

    jessicar | 2009-12-02 - 07:15:04 PM (CDT)
  4. i luv u edwarddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddd
    and jacoooob your sexy

    jezicar | 2009-12-02 - 07:16:01 PM (CDT)
  5. I think that New Moon is 100 times better than Twilight. Even if I haven`t seen the 1st movie I think that the second movie is the best.I hope that the 3rd movie will be much better.my favorite actor is Robert Pattison and Taylor Lautner.I love the movie!

    Tatiana Anne Hudgens | 2009-12-02 - 07:43:27 PM (CDT)
  6. jacob sould be the new edward lol..........i kinda like him as a wolf

    P.A.M | 2009-12-02 - 07:45:08 PM (CDT)
  7. I think you missed the point - Edward doesn’t try to ’get back into her life’ at all - he already has her back. Jacob never replaced him in Bella’s heart. What he is trying to do is protect her from the dangerous volatility of a young werewolf. This will be delved into much further in the next movie.

    Walker | 2009-12-02 - 08:06:24 PM (CDT)
  8. Here come the teeny-boppers...

    Everyone over the age of twelve | 2009-12-02 - 08:12:07 PM (CDT)
  9. i love u taylorrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr so much and the movie was amazing i love when edward wonted to marrie her ! i can not what until the new movie comes out i read all the books they are amazing and taylor u are so sexy in the movie i love u taylor because u are hot and that is why i love u

    khailee | 2009-12-02 - 09:11:20 PM (CDT)
  10. ya
    ya
    ya
    ya
    ya
    ya
    ya
    u are so sexy taylor

    lexi | 2009-12-02 - 09:13:42 PM (CDT)
  11. i <3 the twilight saga new moon it was so hot and taylor lautner was hot with his top off

    9 10 11 12 (13) | 2009-12-02 - 09:15:27 PM (CDT)
  12. new moon is my favorite mvie of all time!!! also edward cullen is soooooooooooooo hot and i want 2 marry him

    Maria | 2009-12-02 - 09:50:38 PM (CDT)
  13. wow. you kids are silly...

    go watch interview with the vampire | 2009-12-02 - 11:31:05 PM (CDT)
  14. The music in Twilight were much better. Nothing in terms of music stands out in New Moon.

    gene4jean | 2009-12-03 - 07:46:42 AM (CDT)
  15. I agree with comment #7. The reason you mentioned for Edward coming back into her life was not how it happened in the books or movie. And that is a very important part.

    Sharon | 2009-12-03 - 12:35:52 PM (CDT)
  16. omg i was reading twilight and i would like do some thing and like i sall edwerd i love loveove edwerd rocks

    Pamela | 2010-01-10 - 06:22:29 AM (CDT)
Your Thoughts,
Name: (required)
To protect everyone from terrible spam, please enter the following code: (required)
captcha
* Offensive comments will be deleted!

ADVERTISEMENTS